Greensill collapse reverberates through Germany

By Joanna England
Administration of Greensill Bank will affect numerous German municipalities connected to the lender...

The collapse of Greensill Bank has sent shockwaves through German communities as the scale and breadth of the crisis is realised.

According to reports, German municipalities held an estimated $600m with the lender that wasn’t covered by deposit insurance or subject to ECB-imposed negative interest rates.

Greensill’s German municipal depositors include the Hesse state capital of Wiesbaden, the university town of Giessen, the Cologne opera, and the sewage plant of a suburb of Hannover. 

In anticipation of the crisis, the German financial watchdog BaFin, froze the operations of the Bremen-based bank last week. BaFin also filed a criminal complaint citing suspected balance sheet manipulation just days before Greensill Capital, filed for insolvency. 

Reports suggest that the expensive rescue of municipalities that had banked with other fallen lenders including Leham Brothers and Maple Bank is to blame. The move resulted in public sector clients of Germany's private sector banks no longer being covered by the country’s deposit insurance scheme in 2017.

But banking experts have heavily criticised the move which now sees municipalities on the brink of losing vast amounts.

Deputy head of the German association of cities and towns, Verena Göppert, called the decision “a mistake as it cannot be properly justified.”

The German Ministry of Finance is also unlikely to provide a safety net for the losses. When asked about the crisis, the government body reportedly pointed to the current regulatory framework, citing the fact that many of the afflicted municipalities are already financially challenged. A spokesman said that German cities are already under huge financial pressures from the Covid-19 pandemic, with falling tax revenue and rising expenditures. 

Greensill fallout

The administration of Greensill is already threatening thousands of jobs across Europe, the UK and Australia as GFG Alliance, which defaulted on its loans to Greensill following a 60% downturn in demand from its steel operations because of the COVID-19 pandemic. 

Greensill, which was backed by SoftBank, specialised in supply chain finance. The fintech filed for insolvency on March 8th after Credit Suisse Group suspended $10bn in funding to the bank.

The demise of Greensill Capital has sent shockwaves through the network of financial and industrial institutions that were dependent on its supply chain funding and the investment opportunities it provided. 

Susannah Streeter, senior investment and markets analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown in London, explained, “For companies reliant on its factoring service, the great scramble has begun to find other ways of covering the looming cavern in their finances. Those investors who had bought the debt sold on the market are now staring at potentially big losses.” 

Apollo Global Management’s $59.5m offer for Greensill’s IT systems and intellectual property. However, the equity firm halted talks following an escalating stand-off with a critical technology provider to the once high-flying supply chain finance group, the FT reported.

Downing Street has also expressed concern, with Boris Johnson’s spokesman issuing a statement saying the situation was “'very worrying. We continue to follow developments closely."

Meanwhile, Greensill Capital issued a public statement via its website saying, "Joint administrators are in continued discussion with an interested party in relation to the purchase of certain Greensill assets. As these remain ongoing, it would be inappropriate to comment at this time."


Featured Articles

Top 10 Middle East fintechs to watch in 2023

As fintech skyrockets in the Middle East, we track the top 10 fintechs to watch in 2023, from all-digital banks to ride-share companies and beyond

Fintech innovation and the alternative finance space

The alternative finance space is gaining ground against traditional institutions, so we take an in-depth look at modern methods of financing

Fintech focus: How to stay resilient during the downturn

As investment opportunities shrink and startups put the brakes on expansion, we spoke to industry experts about how startups can increase resilience

How the economic climate is impacting alternative finance

Financial Services (FinServ)

Has the ‘gamification’ of investing apps gone too far?

Financial Services (FinServ)

Top 10 Digital Reports & Consultancies for the fintech space

Financial Services (FinServ)