Is there a business case for funding a loss-making fintech?

By Peter Stonham, Digital Consultant, Altus
Peter Stonham, Digital Consultant at Altus, examines the wisdom of funding a loss-making fintech and what 'value' in the digital era actually means...

Deliveroo joined the list of companies receiving huge valuations at their IPO last week, started trading at a company valuation of £7.6bn. Whilst this is down from their previously anticipated value of up to £8.9bn, it still represents the biggest IPO offer on the London Stock Exchange since THG in September 2020. Regardless of what happens to the stock in the hours and days post-launch, this is a measurable display of the value of the company at the point of offering.

Looking at the headline numbers of the company though, you’d be forgiven for questioning why it has been valued so highly. After many years of increasing losses, Deliveroo turned profitable on an operating basis for the first time in 2020, arguably thanks to the increase in use by those affected by the Coronavirus pandemic and stay-at-home orders in countries around the world. Still, the company posted an underlying loss of over £220m.

This isn’t a one-off story. Last year’s heavily reported flotation of The Hut Group told the same tale. Three-quarters of the most highly valued venture-backed companies which went public in the US in the latter half of 2020 were posting losses in excess of $100m. Fintech companies are no exception to this practice; just this week PensionBee confirmed its intention to float at a value of at least £300m, despite recording a net operating loss of £6.9m last year.

Yet these companies are still able to attract investment, either from venture-capital investors or on public markets. People see the value of the company in terms of its data, its access to wide markets or its proprietary technologies more so than in its ability to turn a profit. 

Data – and how it is used – is widely seen as an area of most value to businesses, but with the large volumes of data required within Financial Services, are businesses making the most use of it? Successful businesses will make decisions based on logical analysis of their data, rather than relying on qualitative input alone. Deliveroo uses their data to great effect, driving efficiency in their delivery operation through quantitative analysis and prediction of issues, made possible by machine learning models and real-time operational monitoring.

Another area of significant value is the access to the market that a company has. This is seen particularly in the social networking sector. Access to the market is intrinsically linked to a product’s ease of use – are you offering your customers simple and convenient ways of using your product? Deliveroo has certainly been successful with its access to the market, with user-centric, mobile-first user front ends. Core to this is allowing users to access a product in the way that suits them at the time they want to use it.

The third pillar of value to consider is how integral a company can be to the core workflows of others – and therefore how necessary others consider it. Open Banking is becoming ever more core to the propositions of a number of FS institutions across the UK and is no longer the preserve of fintechs (through desire) and retail banks (through legislation). One of the primary players in the Banking Integration market, Plaid, was recently valued at $15bn (according to a Financial Technology Partners report on Open Banking). Collateral from the US Department of Justice suit to block Visa’s acquisition of Plaid in 2020 shows that, in addition to Plaid’s declared business aims of bank connections and account validations, Visa executives saw value in the breadth of Plaid’s connectivity across a wide range of other areas. This would see them using Plaid’s position as a trusted provider of information integration and exchange, to set the company up for future expansion into different business areas.

Wherever your primary value lies, one thing is clear. The technology which supports it needs to be reliable, effective, and ready to scale. Solidifying your in-house knowledge, selecting your technology providers and capitalising on their offerings, and understanding the market integration points of your technical estate are all important steps to take as you run your business on a day-to-day basis, and all the more so when you’re preparing for external scrutiny.

So whether you’re among the world’s largest food delivery companies opening up to public investment, or you’re scaling up a fintech in the UK and starting a new funding round, the message is clear: the value of a company lies in so much more than your ability to deliver(oo) a profit. 

This article was contributed by Peter Stonham, Digital Consultant, Altus


Featured Articles

Defaqto: Helping clients ‘make smarter financial decisions’

We look at the life and career of John Milliken, CEO of Defaqto – a company known for issuing star ratings, but with far more going on under the hood…

WorldFirst: Why now is time for SMEs to seek trade in Asia

In this exclusive interview, we speak to VP of Ant Group and WorldFirst CEO Clara Shi, on why now is the time for UK SMEs to trade in new markets

Mastercard webinar: Shaping the Future of Fintech

Mastercard experts, alongside Zolve CEO and Founder Raghu G, discuss the six major fintech trends today in the company’s latest webinar – available now

Embedded finance: Innovating for good

Financial Services (FinServ)

Live today: FinTech LIVE London

Financial Services (FinServ)

Crypto, blockchain and Web3 speakers at FinTech LIVE London